home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1336>
- <link 94TO0204>
- <title>
- Oct. 03, 1994: Cover:Taking Charge On the Ground
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Oct. 03, 1994 Blinksmanship
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- COVER STORIES, Page 40
- Taking Charge On the Ground
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> After police beat civilians, the U.S. abandons its pretense
- of cooperation, seizes control and draws Haitian blood
- </p>
- <p>By Kevin Fedarko--Reported by Sam Allis, Cathy Booth, Nina Burleigh and Bernard
- Diederich/Port-au-Prince and Edward Barnes/Cap Haitien
- </p>
- <p> The thousands of Haitians who flocked to Port-au-Prince airport
- last Monday afternoon had come to cheer, applaud or just stare
- at the newly arrived U.S. troops. Once there, they could not
- resist the exhilarating urge to shout their joy at the imminent
- return of the man whose name could not be spoken and whose picture
- could not be displayed for the past three years. "Vive Titid!"
- they cried, invoking their affectionate sobriquet for exiled
- President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. "Down with Cedras!" Suddenly,
- two Haitian army officers appeared, dragging a skinny young
- man who was moaning pitifully. His face was bloody. His feet
- were bare. His pants had nearly been ripped off.
- </p>
- <p> Unsure of what to do, a small group of American soldiers, who
- had landed only hours before, stood aside to let the trio pass.
- Once inside the terminal, the Haitian officers began methodically
- beating their silent and defenseless prisoner. Listening to
- the sickening thud of fists on flesh, one of the U.S. soldiers
- turned his face away and exclaimed, "They're really messing
- him up. And we can't do anything."
- </p>
- <p> The violence in the streets only worsened the next day. Hampered
- by strict rules of nonengagement, hundreds of American soldiers
- found themselves watching helplessly as Haiti's blue-uniformed
- police and khaki-clad army troops waded into the capital's crowds,
- swinging metal nightsticks and indiscriminately firing tear-gas
- canisters. In front of the harbor, the Haitian authorities conducted
- brief sorties, beating anyone who fell or faltered. They broke
- up a demonstration by hurtling through the middle of the crowd
- in a van. One police officer attacked bystanders with a yard-long
- crowbar, using the tool's hook to gouge the flesh of his targets.
- Another slammed his truncheon onto the unprotected skull of
- a house painter, killing him. "This is not Europe, my friend,"
- said a Haitian to a nearby journalist. "This is hell."
- </p>
- <p> For Haitians, such abuses under the nose of the Americans who
- had come to rescue them were a shocking dose of the treatment
- they have endured ever since the 1991 coup forced Aristide from
- power. As the U.S. soldiers watched and did nothing, Haitian
- onlookers became increasingly perplexed and hostile. "I know
- you guys are working hard," shouted one man to troops sitting
- on a wall. "But people here are suffering." The inaction only
- heightened the suspicion of collusion. "How could the United
- States be so stupid?" another demanded. "For months you call
- these men thugs, murderers, thieves and drug dealers, and then
- Colin Powell comes down and treats them with honor. Where are
- your brains?"
- </p>
- <p> For the young men who serve in the Army's 10th Mountain Division,
- the brutality offered a firsthand glimpse of the raw intimidation
- that passes for civic order in this country. "We were taught
- to defend these people," said Private First Class Doug Johler.
- "Now, to see what's going on and not be able to do anything,
- it tears you up inside."
- </p>
- <p> In a swift pirouette, the U.S. promised to intervene to quell
- any violence. More than 1,000 U.S. military police were sent
- into the capital, while G.I.s riding aboard machine gun-equipped
- humvees patrolled the streets. However, on Saturday Port-au-Prince
- police broke up a pro-Aristide demonstration using tear gas
- and metal nightsticks on crowds that converged on army and police
- headquarters chanting, "Handcuff Cedras." An American military
- spokesman said U.S. troops did not intervene because they had
- not seen the clashes.
- </p>
- <p> U.S. Marines drew Haitian blood at dusk on Saturday. An evening
- patrol in Cap Haitien stopped across the street from a local
- police station. "Four guys came out from the front desk, saw
- us and got spooked and lit up their weapons," Corporal Mike
- Arnett told the Associated Press. "We returned fire." At least
- nine Haitians were reportedly killed in the brief gunfight;
- two took refuge in the police station, which the Marines besieged.
- One U.S. Marine was injured. U.S. forces sealed off a section
- of Cap Haitien, a major drug-transshipment point in the Caribbean.
- It was not known whether the Marines had engaged policemen or
- the civilian militia. Ugly shadows were being cast over an occupation
- that had begun so benignly.
- </p>
- <p> Earlier, on Tuesday morning, when the Marines of Fox Company
- secured a perimeter of barbed wire around the airport at Cap
- Haitien, scores of delighted Haitians had gathered on the other
- side. They had never seen anything like this display of military
- might, but they sensed it was a good thing for them. They smiled,
- clapped at strangers and responded with generous humor to the
- appalling high school French of reporters. "Do you think they
- came for you?" shouted a gaunt, smiling man into the window
- of a wealthy Haitian's jeep. "You are wrong. They came for me."
- </p>
- <p> The previous morning, 170 miles to the south in Port-au-Prince,
- thousands of Haitians converged on the airport. They were lured
- by the spectacle of 51 Black Hawks touching down on the boiling
- tarmac in tight formation, dropping troops from the 10th Mountain
- Division. Civilians were everywhere: standing on roofs; perched
- atop cars; clinging to the sides of billboards. The crowd watched,
- convinced that an army of wonder workers had arrived to restore
- the President they had elected, redress the injustices they
- had suffered, give back the future that had been stolen from
- them. "The American people are coming to fix up everything,"
- gushed Claude Pierre, a portrait photographer.
- </p>
- <p> Not everyone shared his delight. While the poor cavorted in
- the sweltering sun, wealthy residents of the capital--the
- class whom Americans have taken to calling MREs, short for "morally
- repugnant elites"--drove by in air-conditioned Isuzu Troopers
- and Cherokee Pioneers, their camcorders trained on the action.
- Although many wealthy Haitians welcomed the U.S. troops for
- the protection they provided, some were openly hostile. They
- predicted that the supporters of Aristide would soon turn on
- the aristocracy in the age-old tradition of dechoukage, or "uprooting,"
- in which the poor destroy the homes, property and lives of the
- rich. "It will get out of hand," predicted one man who sported
- an expensive gold necklace that marked him as a member of the
- army's feared paramilitary attaches. "The poor will go after
- everything other people have."
- </p>
- <p> Among the Haitian military men who have been brusquely muscled
- to the sidelines, many now bear the added insult of sharing
- their accommodations with U.S. soldiers. On Friday, while Haitian
- troopers played dominoes on one end of their balcony at the
- capital's general quarters, G.I.s on the other end snoozed in
- the afternoon heat. "How do I feel?" asked a member of the Haitian
- high command. "That's a delicate question." He glanced away
- for a long time, then simply looked back at his guest. The silence
- underscored his humiliation.
- </p>
- <p> Such feelings seemed to matter little to the U.S. soldiers,
- who were preoccupied with the open-arm reception coming from
- the poor. "They know we're here to help," said Specialist Hugh
- Sullivan, manning his machine gun from the top of a humvee.
- In fact, he added ruefully, "they think we're here to solve
- all their problems."
- </p>
- <p> A sobering thought, considering the disappointment such wide-eyed
- anticipation could quickly lead to. Still, the eager welcome
- came as a relief to Sergeant Erik Bartkowiak. He recalled his
- last experience administering U.S. foreign policy--one he
- doesn't care to repeat--in Somalia. There, the first words
- Bartkowiak heard, shouted by a Somali child, were "F*** you,
- American." Confused, ambiguous, frustrating though it was, the
- first week of Clinton's Haiti policy was at least better than
- that.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-